In 2013, Lori Loughlin stepped into the shoes of Jennifer Shannon in the inaugural Garage Sale Mystery film, a loose adaptation drawing inspiration from Suzi Weinert‘s novel, “Garage Sale Stalker.” Portraying the astute owner of an antique store with a penchant for solving murders.
Over the following six years, the Garage Sale Mystery movies gained a dedicated following, featuring Loughlin in every installment alongside a talented cast, including Steve Bacic, Sarah Strange, Eva Bourne, Connor Stanhope, and Kevin O’Grady.
As the series unfolded, fans became immersed in the captivating world of garage sale-themed mysteries, prompting the question: How many Garage Sale Mystery movies exist, and what is the recommended viewing order for this intriguing series?
Join us as we unravel the chronological sequence of the Garage Sale Mystery movies in order, offering you the ideal guide to explore Jennifer Shannon’s evolving investigative skills and the mysterious cases she encounters.
1 ‘Garage Sale Mystery’ (2013)
In the enthralling 2013 mystery film, “Garage Sale Mystery,” Lori Loughlin steps into the role of Jennifer Shannon, the astute protagonist of this gripping film series. Adapted from Suzi Weinert‘s Garage Sale Mystery book series, the plot kicks off when Jennifer stumbles upon a pattern of robberies targeting affluent homes in the aftermath of their garage sales.
The stakes heighten when a woman, seemingly the victim of a tragic accident, raises Jennifer’s suspicions. Convinced that foul play is afoot, Jennifer teams up with Detective Adam Iverson to delve into the intricacies of garage sale culture.
Undeterred, Jennifer’s relentless pursuit of the truth leads her to unveil the identity of the murderer, adding a layer of suspense to this captivating mystery narrative. If you are a fan of light-hearted mysteries with a dash of suspense, “Garage Sale Mystery” promises not just a whodunit, but a thrilling journey into the intricate world of crime-solving
2 ‘Garage Sale Mystery: All That Glitters’ (2014)
In the sequel, “Garage Sale Mystery: All That Glitters,” Lori Loughlin reprises her role as the sharp-witted Jennifer Shannon in this captivating mystery series. Building upon the success of its predecessor, the film follows Jennifer as she becomes entangled in another web of intrigue within the seemingly mundane world of garage sales.
As she navigates the labyrinth of glittering trinkets and hidden secrets, a trail of deception unravels, leading her to confront a cast of characters with motives as elusive as the elusive missing item. With each twist and turn, “Garage Sale Mystery: All That Glitters” keeps audiences on the edge of their seats, delivering a delightful blend of suspense and light-hearted mystery.
As Jennifer Shannon once again takes center stage, fans can anticipate a thrilling continuation of the Garage Sale Mystery series, where every trinket holds a clue, and every sale conceals a secret waiting to be uncovered.
3 ‘Garage Sale Mystery: The Deadly Room’ (2015)
In the compelling installment, “Garage Sale Mystery: The Deadly Room,” Lori Loughlin returns to captivate audiences as the astute Jennifer Shannon. This time, the garage sale aficionado finds herself entangled in a web of danger when a seemingly routine estate sale takes a sinister turn. As Jennifer explores the treasures within an old Victorian home, she stumbles upon more than just forgotten relics.
Determined to uncover the truth, Jennifer dives into a maze of family secrets and long-buried mysteries. With each revelation, “Garage Sale Mystery: The Deadly Room” unfolds as a riveting blend of suspense and investigative prowess.
For fans of the series and newcomers alike, this installment promises a thrilling journey through the hidden corners of vintage treasures, where every sale holds the potential for danger, and every room conceals a deadly secret waiting to be exposed.
4 ‘Garage Sale Mystery: The Wedding Dress’ (2015)
Embarking on another intriguing mystery, “Garage Sale Mystery: The Wedding Dress” reintroduces Lori Loughlin as the perceptive Jennifer Shannon. The narrative unfolds when the owner of the antique store stumbles upon a wedding dress during her quest for captivating items for Rags to Riches. This particular gown, however, isn’t just a vintage find; it harbors a mysterious past, shrouded in the enigma of a missing groom.
Driven by her inherent curiosity and knack for unraveling mysteries, Jennifer delves into a tale that goes beyond the allure of matrimonial nostalgia. As she traverses town, scouring garage sales, estate sales, and storage locker auctions, Jennifer not only seeks intriguing pieces for her shop but often stumbles upon items with cryptic histories.
In “Garage Sale Mystery: The Wedding Dress,” viewers can expect a riveting exploration as Jennifer uncovers the origins of the dress, the individuals involved weaving together a narrative that transcends the ordinary and ventures into the realm of captivating intrigue.
5 ‘Garage Sale Mystery: Guilty Until Proven Innocent’ (2016)
In the riveting chapter, “Garage Sale Mystery: Guilty Until Proven Innocent,” Lori Loughlin reprises her role as antiques guru Jennifer Shannon, thrust into the heart of a compelling murder investigation. The plot thickens when an old college friend finds themselves at the center of the storm as the prime suspect.
Jennifer, armed with her keen intuition and relentless investigative spirit, delves into the labyrinth of clues and uncertainties surrounding the case. As she navigates the intricate world of antiques and the shadows of a seemingly idyllic past, Jennifer must untangle a web of secrets to uncover the truth. The film not only showcases Loughlin’s stellar performance but also features a talented ensemble cast, including Sarah Strange and Steve Bacic.
“Garage Sale Mystery: Guilty Until Proven Innocent” promises viewers a captivating blend of suspense, friendship, and the relentless pursuit of justice, making it another thrilling installment in the enigmatic world of garage sale mysteries.
6 ‘Garage Sale Mystery: The Novel Murders’ (2016)
Embarking on a riveting mystery, “Garage Sale Mystery: The Novel Murders” reintroduces Lori Loughlin as the adept antiques expert Jennifer Shannon. The narrative takes an intriguing turn when, amidst the artifacts of a garage sale, Jennifer uncovers two clues at the scene of a murder that strikingly resemble elements found in a mystery novel.
As the film unfolds, Lori Loughlin‘s stellar portrayal of Jennifer Shannon is complemented by a narrative that not only explores the art of crime-solving but also blurs the lines between literary imagination and the stark realities of a murder investigation.
“Garage Sale Mystery: The Novel Murders” invites viewers to immerse themselves in a tale where the boundaries between the pages of a novel and the gritty world of crime unravel, resulting in a mystery that captivates and challenges the conventional notions of investigation.
7 ‘Garage Sale Mystery: The Art of Murder’ (2017)
In the intriguing tale of “Garage Sale Mystery: The Art of Murder,” the storyline unfolds as Jennifer Shannon, portrayed by Lori Loughlin, embarks on the charitable endeavor of setting up a garage sale. However, the ordinary takes a chilling turn when Jennifer stumbles upon a lifeless body in the attic of a neighboring home.
Fueled by her eye for detail and the unique combination of experience in antiques and crime-solving, Jennifer becomes an unwitting detective. Under the directorial helm of Kristoffer Tabori, the film takes viewers on a journey where Jennifer’s astuteness is put to the test.
“Garage Sale Mystery: The Art of Murder” promises a blend of suspense and investigative prowess, providing audiences with another captivating chapter in the enigmatic world of Jennifer Shannon.
8 ‘Garage Sale Mystery: Murder Most Medieval’ (2017)
Amidst the echoes of the past, “Garage Sale Mystery: Murder Most Medieval” invites viewers to watch the captivating story where Lori Loughlin‘s Jennifer Shannon stumbles upon a dark and intricate mystery. This time, the suspenseful narrative unfolds when Jennifer acquires a suit of armor, only to make a grim discovery, the lifeless body of a local college history professor concealed within its metal embrace.
The stakes escalate as the professor’s teaching assistant becomes the next victim, ensnaring Jennifer in a web of dangerous lies spun by a relentless killer. Directed by Neill Fearnley, the film promises an enthralling exploration of medieval echoes and modern-day danger, providing audiences with a captivating installment in the ongoing adventures of Jennifer Shannon’s crime-solving escapades.
As the plot weaves together secrets of the past and present, Loughlin’s portrayal shines amidst the shadows, making “Garage Sale Mystery: Murder Most Medieval” a compelling addition to the suspenseful series.
9 ‘Garage Sale Mystery: Murder by Text’ (2017)
In the dynamic narrative of “Garage Sale Mystery: Murder by Text,” Lori Loughlin reprises her role as Jennifer Shannon, the resourceful antique store owner adept at unraveling mysteries. The plot takes a poignant turn when a bass player is discovered dead just before embarking on a scheduled tour with a prominent country singer.
This unexpected demise sets off Jennifer’s investigative instincts, casting doubt on the circumstances surrounding the musician’s death. The film unfolds various storylines, including Jennifer’s partner Dani’s unexpected family visit, which takes an unforeseen twist.
Under the directorial guidance of Neill Fearnley, “Garage Sale Mystery: Murder by Text” promises a compelling fusion of suspense, family dynamics, and Jennifer’s unyielding quest for the truth, making it another enthralling chapter in the hallmark series.
10 ‘Garage Sale Mystery: The Beach Murder’ (2017)
Another top mystery addition, “Garage Sale Mystery: The Beach Murder,” unfolds as Jennifer lends her expertise to a grieving widow suspicious of foul play in her husband’s demise—an avid surfer and swimmer found lifeless on an isolated beach, purportedly a victim of drowning. In the rhythmic cadence of ocean waves, Jennifer’s investigative instincts are stirred as she questions the presumed drowning of a surfer.
Despite the initial narrative, the surfer’s wife disputes the account, arguing that her husband’s swimming proficiency contradicts such an end. Under the guidance of Neill Fearnley, the film immerses itself in a narrative current that scrutinizes the enigmatic beach murder while seamlessly weaving with Jennifer’s personal journey.
“Garage Sale Mystery: The Beach Murder” beckons viewers into a space where secrets ebb and flow like the tide, promising another captivating chapter in the hallmark series.
11 ‘Garage Sale Mystery: A Case of Murder’ (2017)
In the riveting episode of “Garage Sale Mystery: A Case of Murder” (2017) the story takes an ominous turn when Jennifer acquires an old reel-to-reel recorder at a garage sale, only to discover it harbors the chilling sound of a man pleading for his life. The investigation unveils the recorder’s owner, Dr. Vedders, who met a tragic end, having been stabbed to death.
Dr. Vedders, entangled in personal issues with his wife and professionally serving as a psychologist to a group of patients, was found dead on the day of his retirement. As Jennifer delves deeper into this perplexing case, her own safety becomes jeopardized, setting the stage for a thrilling collaboration with a detective.
Airing on August 27, 2017, “Garage Sale Mystery: A Case of Murder” promises an enthralling blend of suspense, psychological intrigue, and Jennifer Shannon’s relentless determination to solve yet another enigmatic mystery in the hallmark series.
12 ‘Garage Sale Mystery: The Pandora’s Box Murders’ (2018)
In the unfolding narrative of “Garage Sale Mystery: The Pandora’s Box Murders,” Lori Loughlin reprises her role as Jennifer Shannon, the astute antique store owner. The storyline takes a compelling turn as Jennifer is enlisted by the daughter-in-law of a prestigious family to unravel the secrets concealed within a mysterious puzzle box left behind by her mother-in-law.
The enigmatic puzzle box becomes the focal point of the investigation, leading Jennifer into a tangled web of family mysteries and hidden histories. As she delves into the complexities of this intriguing case, the film promises an exploration of familial intricacies and Jennifer Shannon’s relentless dedication to solving the puzzle behind “The Pandora’s Box Murders.”
For those eager to embark on the journey of “Garage Sale Mystery,” be prepared for a riveting exploration of enigmatic tales, where this installment unfolds like a puzzle waiting to be solved.
13 ‘Garage Sale Mystery: The Mask Murder’ (2018)
Embarking on another intriguing chapter, “Garage Sale Mystery: The Mask Murder” places Lori Loughlin in the role of amateur detective Jen, the discerning antique store owner. The narrative takes a spine-chilling turn as Jen stumbles upon a young woman’s lifeless body in a storage locker, having acquired the contents at an auction for her store.
While the rest of the family is occupied with the noble task of building homeless housing, Jen’s innate investigative instincts draw her irresistibly into the unfolding mystery. As Jen delves into solving “The Mask Murder,” this installment promises a riveting tale filled with suspense and unforeseen twists. Lori Loughlin‘s portrayal lends depth to Jen’s character, portraying her as both inquisitive and resolute in the pursuit of justice.
Brace yourselves for another captivating journey in the Garage Sale Mystery series as Jen takes center stage in her relentless quest for truth.
14 ‘Garage Sale Mysteries: Picture a Murder’ (2018)
As the previous series laid the groundwork for intricate mysteries, “Garage Sale Mysteries: Picture a Murder” continues the trend with a fresh enigma. In this installment, a wealthy photography enthusiast meets an alleged accidental demise, leaving behind an antique camera that catches the discerning eye of Jenn at an auction. However, what unfolds when Jenn develops the photos found inside the camera leaves her utterly astonished – the circumstances surrounding the death appear far from accidental.
The narrative unfolds with the revelation contained in a single frame, setting the stage for a captivating exploration of deception, secrets, and unforeseen twists. As Jennifer Shannon once again steps into the role of the amateur detective, viewers can anticipate a unique blend of suspense, investigative intrigue, and the distinctive charm of antique treasures.
Join Jenn in “Garage Sale Mysteries: Picture a Murder” as she unravels a captivating mystery, surpassing mere coincidence.
15 ‘Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder In D Minor’ (2018)
As the series is approaching its conclusion, “Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder In D Minor” adds a riveting chapter to the captivating saga. Jennifer secures the winning bid on a vintage Welte-Mignon piano player at a local estate auction, delving into the echoes of its keys that reveal an intricate tale.
Unveiling the dark history of the philanthropist Karl Dietz, Jennifer’s discovery thrusts her into an enthralling mystery. Her purchase leads her down a series of clues, unmasking the not-so-charitable life of the previous owner before their untimely demise.
The resonant chords of “Murder In D Minor” set the stage for a compelling conclusion, promising suspense, unexpected revelations, and a fitting end to the intricate web of mysteries woven throughout the series.
16 ‘Garage Sale Mysteries: Searched & Seized’ (2020)
With “Garage Sale Mysteries: Searched & Seized,” the mind-blowing mystery series comes to an end, delivering a compelling finale to Jennifer Shannon’s investigative journey. In this concluding entry, Jenn’s friend Miles takes the spotlight, running a police auction featuring items seized in a money counterfeiting operation.
However, the plot takes a dark turn as Miles is found dead, prompting Jennifer to suspect that his involvement with criminals may have been an attempt to solve his debt problems.
The narrative weaves a web of intrigue around a police auction tied to a money counterfeiting scheme, unraveling secrets and leading to unexpected revelations. A suspenseful and fitting conclusion, this installment is a must-watch for mystery enthusiasts looking for a satisfying end to the entire saga.
Conclusion
As we wrap up the journey through the intriguing world of Garage Sale Mystery movies in order, the concluding note brings a sense of closure to the saga. From the first captivating installment to the final revelation in “Searched & Seized,” the series takes viewers on an immersive exploration of mysteries hidden within the artifacts of everyday life.
The garage sale mystery ending, especially in the last entry, “Searched & Seized,” unfolds with suspense, showcasing Jennifer Shannon’s adept investigative prowess one last time.
For those who appreciate the thrill of uncovering hidden truths and relish the intricate dance between artifacts and enigma, the Garage Sale Mystery movies offer a compelling and satisfying journey.
Senior Writer, BuddyTV
Experienced Writer and Graphics Designer
